Maintaining a safe and secure physical environment is critical for protecting sensitive data and systems. The Secure Area Policy and Procedures control from the Cloud Security Alliance Cloud Controls Matrix provides guidance on establishing, documenting, and maintaining policies and procedures to ensure offices, rooms, and facilities housing IT assets and data remain protected. Let's explore why this matters and how to put it into practice.

Where did this come from?

This control comes from the CSA Cloud Controls Matrix v4.0.10 - 2023-09-26. You can download the latest version of the CCM here.

The CCM provides a comprehensive set of security controls specially designed for cloud computing environments. It was developed by the Cloud Security Alliance, a not-for-profit organization dedicated to defining best practices for secure cloud computing.

Who should care?

This control is relevant for several roles:

• Datacenter managers responsible for maintaining a secure physical environment
• Compliance officers ensuring adherence to security standards and regulations
• IT leaders overseeing the organization's security posture
• Risk managers assessing threats to physical security

What is the risk?

Failure to implement proper physical security controls can lead to:

• Unauthorized access to sensitive areas housing critical IT infrastructure
• Theft or tampering of equipment resulting in data loss or system outages
• Eavesdropping or "shoulder surfing" leading to disclosure of confidential information
• Damage from natural disasters disrupting operations

While technical security controls like encryption help protect data, they are rendered moot if an attacker can gain direct physical access to systems. Robust policies and procedures around physical security are an essential compliment.

What's the care factor?

For organizations dealing with sensitive data or mission-critical systems, the care factor for physical security should be quite high. Regulated industries like finance and healthcare have explicit requirements around maintaining secure facilities.

Even for companies not bound by regulation, physical security should still be a priority. Reputational damage and loss of customer trust stemming from a physical breach can be devastating.

When is it relevant?

Secure Area policies and procedures are relevant whenever an organization maintains its own datacenter or office space housing IT infrastructure and data. This includes on-premises servers as well as "private cloud" deployments.

They are less relevant for companies operationally entirely in the public cloud, as the major providers maintain state-of-the-art physical security at their facilities. However, it's still important to understand their practices.

What are the trade-offs?

Implementing rigorous physical security has costs and trade-offs:

• Access controls like keycard readers, biometric scanners, and security guards add expense
• Strict security procedures can be seen as a burden by employees
• Overly restrictive policies may hamper productivity (e.g. vendor access for repairs)
• Opportunity cost - budget allocated to physical security could be invested elsewhere

It's important to strike the right balance between security and usability based on the organization's unique risk profile and tolerance.

How to make it happen?

Here are some key steps to implement a Secure Area policy and procedures:

1. Identify areas in offices and datacenters requiring protection, such as:
   • Server rooms
   • Wiring closets
   • Storage areas holding sensitive information
   • Workstations used to access confidential systems
2. Define security zones with increasing levels of access control. For example:
   • Public spaces like lobbies require only modest restrictions
   • General office areas accessible only to employees and authorized guests
   • Sensitive zones like server rooms restricted to essential personnel
3. Deploy physical access controls appropriate to each zone, such as:
   • Locks and keys
   • Programmable keycards
   • Biometric scanners for high-security areas
   • Visitor log and escort requirements
4. Implement monitoring and logging for sensitive areas
   • Security cameras
   • Door access logs
   • Alerting for unusual access patterns
5. Ensure server rooms and datacenters have appropriate environmental controls:
   • Robust HVAC to maintain optimal temperature
   • Fire suppression systems
   • Moisture detection
   • Seismic safeguards if in an earthquake-prone area
6. Provide for secure disposal of physical media and paper records
   • Shredders
   • Secure disposal bins
   • Procedures for thorough sanitization of storage devices
7. Document all policies and procedures
   • Specify who is authorized to access each area
   • Define processes for granting and revoking access
   • Record instructions for proper use of physical access controls
8. Communicate policies to all personnel and provide training as needed
9. Audit and review the policies and their implementation at least annually

What are some gotchas?

• Compliance with fire codes and occupancy rules may restrict security options in some situations
• Installation of certain controls may require a licensed contractor and/or permits
• Some controls like security cameras could infringe on employee privacy if used improperly - legal counsel should review
• Access to server rooms and other sensitive areas often requires highly privileged permissions to configure - these should be tightly restricted
• Biometric data, while a strong control, has special handling requirements under certain privacy laws

What are the alternatives?

For companies looking to outsource physical security, colocation facilities provide an option to house servers in a professionally managed secure environment. This shifts much of the security burden to the provider.

Various Managed Security Services Providers (MSSPs) also offer "remote hands" options to handle physical security tasks in an organization's own datacenters or remote sites.

Explore Further

• ISO/IEC 27002:2013 Section 11 - Physical and Environmental Security
• NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 - PE: Physical and Environmental Protection Family
• CIS Control 10: Data Recovery (formerly "Physical Protection")
• CIS Control 13: Network Monitoring and Defense

Physical security is a critical layer in a complete security program. The CSA CCM Secure Area Policy and Procedures control provides a solid foundation to protect an organization's most sensitive assets. By carefully developing and consistently implementing the prescribed policies, companies can manage physical security risks in a practical, balanced way.

?