Key activation is a critical step in the lifecycle of cryptographic keys. It's the process of taking a key that has been generated but not yet authorized for use, and making it ready to encrypt data. By carefully controlling key activation, organizations can ensure keys are only used when appropriate and maintain the security of their encrypted data.

Where did this come from?

This article is based on the CSA Cloud Controls Matrix v4.0.10 - 2023-09-26, which you can download from https://cloudsecurityalliance.org/artifacts/cloud-controls-matrix-v4. The CCM provides a controls framework for cloud security that is aligned to many industry-accepted standards, best practices, and regulations. For more background, check out the AWS Key Management Service Developer Guide: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/kms/latest/developerguide/overview.html

Who should care?

• Security engineers responsible for designing and implementing key management solutions
• Compliance officers who need to ensure cryptographic controls meet regulatory requirements
• Developers building applications that leverage encryption to protect sensitive data

What is the risk?

Failing to properly control key activation can lead to several adverse outcomes:

• Keys could be used before they are intended, potentially exposing data
• Unauthorized individuals may be able to activate keys and gain access to encrypted data
• Inability to prove keys were adequately protected throughout their lifecycle for compliance purposes

CEK-15 provides guidelines to mitigate these risks by establishing processes to securely transition keys from a pre-activated to activated state.

What's the care factor?

For any system that uses encryption, key activation controls are essential. Leaked or prematurely used keys completely undermine the security of encrypted data. While implementation requires some effort, the consequences of getting it wrong are severe. This should be a high priority for most organizations, especially those beholden to data protection regulations.

When is it relevant?

Key activation is relevant anytime you are generating keys to use for encryption now or in the future. It is especially important when:

• You have compliance obligations around key management (e.g. PCI-DSS, FIPS 140-2)
• Encryption keys protect highly sensitive data
• Keys have a long lifecycle and may need to be activated far in the future

For simple applications with no specific security requirements, the overhead of a formal key activation process may be overkill. Default key management settings are often adequate in these cases.

What are the trade offs?

Implementing granular controls around key activation comes with costs:

• Additional engineering time to design and implement activation workflows
• Potential reliability issues if activation fails and keys become unavailable
• Reduced agility since key use requires more planning and approval
• More complexity to manage, document and troubleshoot

However, for sensitive data and regulated environments, these trade-offs are usually well worth the security and compliance benefits.

How to make it happen?

Here's a high-level process to implement key activation controls:

1. Design your key lifecycle and define activation criteria
   • When should keys be activated after generation?
   • How long should they remain activated?
   • What approvals are required for activation?
2. Implement technical controls to enforce the activation criteria
   • Use key management systems that support activation workflows
   • Automate key activation processes where possible
3. Establish monitoring and logging for key activation events
   • Ensure all activation attempts are logged and monitored
   • Set up alerts for unauthorized activation attempts
4. Regularly review and update the key activation process
   • Conduct periodic audits to ensure compliance with activation policies
   • Adjust the process based on changes in regulatory requirements or organizational needs

What are some gotchas?

When implementing key activation controls, be aware of the following potential pitfalls:

• Complexity in integration: Integrating key activation processes with existing systems and workflows can be challenging and may require significant custom development.
• Human error: Manual steps in the activation process can lead to mistakes, such as activating the wrong key or failing to deactivate a key when no longer needed.
• Dependency on key management systems: Relying heavily on key management systems means any failure or downtime in these systems can impact your ability to activate or use keys.
• Regulatory changes: Keeping up with evolving regulatory requirements can necessitate frequent updates to your key activation processes, adding to the maintenance burden.

What are the alternatives?

While key activation is a robust control mechanism, there are alternative approaches to managing key usage:

• Automatic key rotation: Regularly rotating keys can limit the impact of a compromised key without the need for a formal activation process.
• Time-based access controls: Implementing time-based restrictions on key usage can provide a simpler alternative to activation controls.
• Context-aware access controls: Using contextual information (such as user location or device) to dynamically control key usage can enhance security without the complexity of activation workflows.

Each of these alternatives has its own trade-offs in terms of security, complexity, and operational impact. The best approach depends on your specific security requirements and operational constraints.

Explore further

To dive deeper into the topic of key activation and related controls, consider exploring the following resources:

• NIST Special Publication 800-57: Provides comprehensive guidelines on key management, including key lifecycle management and activation. Read more here.
• OWASP Cryptographic Storage Cheat Sheet: Offers practical advice on implementing cryptographic controls, including key management practices. Access the cheat sheet.
• AWS Key Management Service (KMS) Documentation: Detailed documentation on how to use AWS KMS for key management, including activation and rotation. Explore the documentation.
• Azure Key Vault Documentation: Microsoft's guide to using Azure Key Vault for key management, which includes key activation and access control best practices. Read the documentation.

By exploring these resources, you can gain a deeper understanding of key activation practices and how to implement them effectively in your organization.

‍