Data classification is a critical process for organizing an organization's data based on its sensitivity level. By categorizing data into different classes such as public, confidential, or restricted, appropriate security controls can be applied to protect the data throughout its lifecycle. Implementing a robust data classification scheme is essential for maintaining the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of sensitive information assets.

Where did this come from?

This control comes from the CSA Cloud Controls Matrix v4.0.10 released on 2023-09-26. The Cloud Controls Matrix (CCM) is a cybersecurity control framework for cloud computing, composed of 197 control objectives structured in 17 domains. It can be downloaded from the Cloud Security Alliance website.

The CCM provides a controls framework that gives detailed understanding of security concepts and principles that are aligned to the Cloud Security Alliance guidance in 17 domains. DSP-04 is part of the Data Security & Privacy Lifecycle Management domain.

Who should care?

Several roles within an organization should be concerned with proper data classification:

• Chief Information Security Officers (CISOs) responsible for overall cybersecurity strategy and governance
• Data Protection Officers (DPOs) tasked with ensuring compliance with data privacy regulations
• Information Security Managers who oversee the implementation of security controls
• Data Owners accountable for the protection and use of specific datasets
• All Employees who handle sensitive data as part of their job duties

What is the risk?

Without data classification, organizations face several risks:

• Data Breaches - Sensitive data may be inadvertently exposed if not properly identified and secured. Data classification helps prevent unauthorized disclosure.
• Compliance Violations - Many data privacy laws and industry standards (e.g. GDPR, HIPAA, PCI-DSS) require data classification. Non-compliance can result in hefty fines and reputational damage.
• Operational Inefficiency - Applying the same level of protection to all data is expensive and impractical. Classification allows security efforts to be focused on the most critical assets.

Proper data classification can significantly reduce the likelihood and impact of these adverse events. However, it is not a silver bullet. Classification must be combined with other security best practices to be fully effective.

What's the care factor?

For organizations that handle large volumes of sensitive data, data classification should be a top priority. The costs of a data breach or compliance violation can be devastating. According to IBM, the average cost of a data breach in 2022 was $4.35 million.

Even for smaller firms, data classification is still important. It demonstrates a basic level of security competence that customers and partners expect. Skipping this fundamental control puts the business at risk.

Data classification requires ongoing effort to implement and maintain. But given the potential consequences, it's an investment every organization needs to make. The care factor should be high.

When is it relevant?

Data classification is relevant in situations such as:

• Migrating data to the cloud
• Sharing data with third parties
• Storing data in databases and file shares
• Disposing of data at the end of its lifecycle

Some examples of data that should definitely be classified include:

• Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
• Protected Health Information (PHI)
• Financial records
• Intellectual property

Data classification may be less critical for:

• Publicly available information
• Low-value, non-sensitive data
• Test datasets containing dummy values

However, it's generally a good practice to classify all data by default. Unnecessary classifications can always be removed. But unclassified sensitive data is a major liability.

What are the trade offs?

Implementing data classification comes with some costs and drawbacks:

• Time & Effort - Classifying data, especially large volumes of unstructured data, takes significant work. Automated tools can help but manual review is often still necessary.
• Potential Productivity Impacts - User productivity may suffer if too many restrictions are placed on accessing and using data. There's a balance between security and usability.
• Training & Human Error - Employees must understand and properly apply classification policies. Mistakes are inevitable. Ongoing training is required.

However, in most cases, the security benefits of data classification will outweigh the costs. The key is to implement classification schemes judiciously based on the organization's data and risk tolerance.

How to make it happen?

Here are some basic steps to implement data classification:

1. Define Classification Levels - Establish clear categories for data sensitivity (e.g. Public, Private, Restricted, Confidential). Familiarize yourself with classification models like Carnegie Mellon Data Classification Guidelines
2. Catalog Data Assets - Identify all the data assets in your environment and assign ownership. This includes databases, file shares, cloud storage, backups, etc.
3. Conduct Data Discovery - Use automated scanning tools to identify sensitive data based on predefined patterns (e.g. credit card numbers, SSNs). Don't forget about unstructured data like documents and emails. Popular tools include:
   • Amazon Macie - Discovers and protects sensitive data in AWS
   • Microsoft Purview - AI powered data classification
   • Varonis Data Classification - Classifies data on-premises and in the cloud
4. Apply Classifications - Tag data with its assigned classification metadata. Most tools allow you to configure classification rules and apply tags automatically. Be sure to involve data owners to validate results.
5. Implement Handling Procedures - Define and enforce policies for how each class of data should be used, stored, transmitted, and disposed of. Communicate these requirements to all employees. Audit for compliance.
6. Review & Maintain - Data classification is not a one-time exercise. As data is created and modified, classifications need to be kept up-to-date. Conduct periodic reviews and reclassify data as needed.

What are some gotchas?

Some implementation challenges and considerations:

• Cloud Requirements - If you're using cloud services like Amazon S3 or Azure Storage, make sure you understand the tools and options available for classifying cloud-based data. Classification metadata fields may differ from on-premises.
• Data Subject to Regulations - Certain regulated data sets (e.g. HIPAA, FedRAMP, Export-controlled) have very specific classification requirements which must be mapped to your own schema.
• Legacy Data - Don't focus only on new data. Historical data not previously classified needs to be analyzed as well, which can be a huge effort depending on volume and location.
• Employee Training - Besides tools, you need institutional discipline in classifying data appropriately. Users should know how to manually classify documents and communicate sensitivity.

What are the alternatives?

While data classification with tagging is considered a best practice, some potential alternatives to explore:

• Folder-Based Classification - Instead of tagging files, simply organizing data into folders with clearly defined security controls (e.g. open vs restricted shares).
• Database Classification - For structured data, classifying at the column or table level within a database rather than individual data elements.
• User Access Controls - Rather than classifying the data itself, focus on configuring granular access controls (authentication and authorization) around sensitive datasets.
• Database Activity Monitoring - Behavioral analysis of data access patterns to detect potential unauthorized use of sensitive information.

These approaches can complement or combine with traditional data classification methods as part of an overall data protection strategy. The right mix depends on the organization.

Explore further

Some relevant materials to learn more:

• SANS Institute: Tagging Data to Prevent Data Leakage - Explains how to tag sensitive data to enable DLP policies
• NIST SP 800-60 Guide for Mapping Types of Information and Systems to Security Categories - Federal guidelines for mapping security impact levels to data types
• ISO/IEC 27001 Annex A.8.2 Information Classification - Classification requirements as part of ISO 27001 standard
• AWS Data Classification Whitepaper - How to classify data in the AWS cloud environment

This control relates to several other controls in the CCM framework, such as DSP-08 (Data Labeling), DSP-02 (Data Inventory), G

‍